Poshmark vs Depop vs Grailed in 2026: Fees, Buyers, and Where Sellers Keep More

List the same $150 vintage jacket on all three apps and the platform decides whether you keep $120, $130.78, or $144.60. That is a $24.60 spread on one sale, and it comes entirely from fee structures, not from anything you did differently. If you sell clothing, sneakers, or streetwear on the side, picking the right app is worth more than most pricing tricks.

Here is the fee math as published on each platform's own fee pages in mid 2026, what kind of buyer actually lives on each app, and the honest answer to where different items sell best. All percentages below are the published US rates; international rates and optional promotions differ.

The fee structures, straight from the fee pages

Poshmark keeps the simplest and steepest structure: a flat $2.95 fee on anything that sells under $15, and a flat 20 percent commission on anything at $15 or above. Payment processing is included, and there are no listing fees. Poshmark's pitch is that the 20 percent buys you its social selling machine, shipping labels included in the flow, and a buyer base that expects boutique-style closets.

Depop made the biggest move of the last two years: it dropped its 10 percent seller commission for US sellers back in July 2024 and shifted its cut to the buyer side as a marketplace fee. As of mid 2026, US sellers pay only payment processing, which runs about 3.3 percent plus 45 cents per order. On paper, Depop is now the cheapest mainstream place in the US to sell secondhand fashion. The tradeoff is that buyers see fees added at checkout, which effectively pushes your listed price up without you seeing that margin.

Grailed sits in the middle: a 9 percent commission plus payment processing of about 3.49 percent plus 49 cents. All-in, that is roughly 12.5 to 12.8 percent on typical menswear price points. Grailed's argument for the middle-tier fee is buyer quality: it remains the default marketplace for men's streetwear, archive pieces, and designer, where buyers arrive knowing exactly what a piece is worth.

The math on real sales

Percentages hide the story, so here is what you actually keep at four common price points. Numbers are computed from the published rates above and rounded to the cent; shipping and supplies excluded.

Two things jump out. First, Depop's flat processing fee means its advantage grows with price: on a $300 designer piece, Depop leaves almost $50 more in your pocket than Poshmark. Second, Poshmark's 20 percent is brutal precisely in the $15 to $50 range where most casual closet clearouts live. Selling a $40 top for a $32 payout, before you pack a single polymailer, is the quiet reason so many sellers drift off the app.

What a year of side selling looks like

Stretch that over a modest year of flipping: eight sales a month at a $60 average is $5,760 in gross sales. On Poshmark that costs $1,152 in fees. On Grailed, about $766. On Depop, about $233. The gap between the cheapest and most expensive platform is over $900 a year at hobby volume, and it scales linearly from there. Fee drag is the one cost you lock in the moment you choose where to list.

Fees are not the whole story: who is actually buying

If fees were everything, Depop would have emptied the other two by now. It has not, because the apps have genuinely different buyers.

Poshmark skews toward US women's fashion, mainstream and contemporary brands, and shoppers who browse closets like boutiques. Sharing, parties, and offers-to-likers still move inventory here in a way that passive listings never match. Everyday brands that would die on Grailed can clear in days on Poshmark, and the built-in shipping flow keeps transactions painless.

Depop is the Gen Z platform: Y2K, vintage, upcycled, and trend-cycle pieces with strong photos. Listings behave like social posts, and sellers with a defined aesthetic build follower bases that buy repeatedly. The weakness is price ceiling: high-ticket designer moves slower to a younger audience, and buyer-side fees at checkout can stall negotiations on bigger numbers.

Grailed is where menswear knowledge lives. Rick Owens, Arc'teryx, raw denim, archive Japanese labels, hyped streetwear: buyers know market prices and pay them. Sneakers sell here too, especially worn or styled pairs that StockX will not take. The flip side is a smaller total audience and slower movement for anything outside the menswear-and-streetwear lane; women's mainstream fashion mostly does not belong on Grailed.

Shipping, offers, and the friction you feel weekly

Poshmark bundles flat-rate priority shipping that the buyer usually pays, which simplifies your life but inflates the buyer's all-in cost on cheap items. Depop and Grailed both let you choose your own labels or set shipping charges, which is more work and more control. All three run offer systems; Grailed leans hardest on haggling culture, so price your listings expecting offers 15 to 25 percent under ask. None of the three authenticate the way StockX or GOAT do on sneakers, so your photos and seller history carry the trust load.

The verdict, by what you are selling

For a mixed closet clearout of everyday women's brands, Poshmark still converts best despite the worst fees; treat the 20 percent as a marketing spend. For vintage, Y2K, and trend pieces with good photography, Depop is the clear answer in 2026: near-zero seller fees and the right eyeballs. For menswear, streetwear, designer, and worn sneakers, Grailed's educated buyers justify its middle-tier cut, and pieces routinely sell for more there than the same item fetches elsewhere. High-volume sellers increasingly cross-list on two of the three and let sell-through decide.

Frequently asked questions

If you want the resale math already run when prices move, get our release alerts: one email when it matters, silence when it does not.

Keep reading